Misleading Punctuation

Sun 22 Nov 2026
This is a clue from my latest puzzle and, as it’s only a 3-letter word, I don’t mind spoiling it here for anyone who might want to solve the puzzle (he said hopefully). Little jumper, with cap, lost in grassland (3) = (f)LEA Fez has commented “I think the commas … stop the clue from working as it should - they affect the grammar so it doesn't mean what you intend”. I agree that the commas affect the meaning but, given my failure to find any sort of misleading definition, I was actually happy that the punctuation obfuscated the meaning. Do I need to add “punctuation may deceive” to the puzzle's preamble? Or is it just flat-out unfair to use misleading punctuation like this? Thoughts?

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

6 comments

There is a school of thought that all punctuation can be ignored. Minute cryptic often have unfair punctuation and clearly subscribe to that. So there is precedent for unfair punctuation like the second comma in your clue. Personally that's the sort of clue that means I'm less likely to bother with the rest of the puzzle as I wouldn't feel able to trust the setter.

B
Last reply 6 hr agoView thread

I will leave the answer to others but "Little jumper with cap lost in grassland (3)" actually seems a better surface to me - the little jumper losing his cap in the grass is just as effective an image as the cap-wearing jumper losing himself in the grass.

B
E
S
Last reply 1 hr agoView thread