Nouns as anagrinds?

Sat 7 Nov 2026
I'm new at this setting business and I want to learn, so when my fourth effort was ready I asked for a test solve. The tester pointed out four instances where I'd used nouns as anagrinds and suggested that I use nounal phrases instead. I redid one of those four clues entirely for other reasons. The other three were easy to change and I did so. The original version of one of the four was: "Waste management can create hard work." That was easily changed to: "Management of waste can create hard work." I think it's still a good clue that way, but I prefer the original. My thinking is that so long as the anagram involves only one word, the nounal anagrind makes for a fair clue. If I'd been trying to clue "sweatshop," I would not have used "hops waste management," but because it's just one word, I think "waste management" works fine for "sweat." I hope someone will point out what I'm missing.

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

3 comments

Here's site-owner Raider's take on the matter: https://www.mycrossword.co.uk/blog/are-nouns-valid-anagram-indicators

More seriously, very occasionally I will see one in the wild here and think "hm, that was actually okay". But then I have to slap myself on the wrist. In general, people really don't like them, and at the end of the day, I'm setting for the solver more than for myself. The ones that come closest are where the noun indicator appears in a set phrase, and in that phrase plays the role of indicating the "rearrangement" of the other elements in that phrase.

N
Last reply 2 hr agoView thread