Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

18 comments

Welcome to MyC Shorty! Pretty impressive debut, with lots to like and some clever, witty cluing. I particularly enjoyed 15a, 20a, 22a, 2d, 5d, 9d among others. I have queries about some others (eg 10a, 12a, 24d) but don’t feel able to offer feedback in the absence of annotated solutions switched on (in setting tools). But welcome again and hope to see more from you.

F
O
S
Last reply 9 mo agoView thread

Welcome Shorty and thanks for a fun debut with plenty to enjoy. My faves were 11a, 23a, 25a, 26a, 3d & 18d. A few spoilery comments ...

S
F
Last reply 9 mo agoView thread

Thanks Shorty and welcome to MyC. I thought that was an excellent debut. My top picks were 11a, 15a, 23a, 3d, and 21d. More in reply.

S
G
Last reply 9 mo agoView thread

Thanks Shorty and a belated welcome to MyC from me to. I also thought this an excellent debut puzzle. Favourites: 11a, 23a, 26a, 1d, 3d, 13d and 21d. Spoilers …

C
Last reply 9 mo agoView thread

Very late to this, Shorty, but at least I managed to get around to it before the week was up! Welcome to MyC; as others have said, you've produced a super debut and I like many of your constructions. Annotations would certainly be helpful as I am not 100% certain of some parsing. 19a has me a little confused. My bigger ticks went to 11a, 15a, 23a, 1d, 5d, 9d and 17d (COTD). I wouldn't have considered 18d to be 'heavy' but Wiki backs you up. Thanks. PM

S
P
C
Last reply 9 mo agoView thread

Deleted

Super fun puzzle, thanks. I really liked 1d and quite a few others, e.g., 11a, 9d, 15a... really glad I went back and checked this out. Thank you.