Special Instructions: This is my first attempt at setting a cryptic crossword - any feedback or improvements anyone can suggest would be really appreciated. Thank you!

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

7 comments

Thanks, HF. Some fun clues here, including 5a, 8a, 4d (my fav), and 2d (which might not need a QM; others can weigh in there). In the "Actions" pull-down menu, the "Solutions & explanations" button allows you to make your annotations visible to solvers (recommended). Nice debut with a range of techniques; keep it up.

H
Last reply 16 hr agoView thread

Thanks HF and welcome to MyC. Liked 2d and 4d in particular; I didn't really understand 1a and 6d but I guessed them correctly. Enabling annotations will help with feedback as tpg mentioned. I always recommend the Chambers Crossword Manual by Don Manley, the Chambers dictionary app, and clueclinic.com to new setters. Good luck.

F
Last reply 17 hr agoView thread

Well done a good first effort not loads to worry about just some refining I had similar thoughts about the muddy 1a and the probably unnecessary question mark in 2d. 5a 7a & 4d good solid clues. The definition for 6d is a little vague but it is balanced by a very clear homophone. I wonder if students still talk about a Desmond? Keep it up :)

Thanks HF, very nice debut faves were 8a, 3d and 4d, look forward to your next one, cheers 🕷️