Alternative formats for definitions
I generally err to a base format for definitions in clues. Something akin to "technically correct description of the meaning of the answer, or definition by example that is also technically correct". That could be a direct synonym, or a short few words, that describe the meaning of the answer. A definition as might appear in a dictionary, albeit perhaps with some clever cryptically chosen phrasing.
What I'm wondering about is what people think about definitions that don't exactly fit that pattern. In particular:
1. Definitions for a term describing category of person that use the form "I...", as in something like "I wonder" for "DAYDREAMER".
2. Definitions that are written as a response to the question "What is..." without being written as "dictionary definitions". Things like "that's...", "it..." or "it's...", as in something like "It takes some beating" as the definition for "PUNCHING BAG".
3. Definitions that are phrases that could substitute the answer, but do not form either technical descriptions of meaning or DBE. For example, "Gross" for "UGH", or "I say" for "GOODNESS". In this case it's "another way you could express the same idea", though not a "synonym", I think.
My thoughts: I dislike #1 but I'm fine with #2 and #3. I think "One [who]..." instead of "I..." is fine, which is more like category #2 - the word isn't the one speaking the clue to you, after all. And I think "phrase that could be substituted directly with the same conveyed meaning" is an acceptable form of definitions (#3).
Sign in to leave a comment
Sign in to leave a comment
Be the first to reply!
0 comments