Reverse engineering clues

Sat 31 Oct 2026
I think clues that require reverse engineering can be fun and add a bit of variety to a puzzle. My feeling is these are popular clues for solvers, but would be interested: 1. to hear other views; do you like to solve these types of clues? 2. Do you like them indicated or are you happy with a simple question mark? Eg, just the QM? Arm with treasure? (4,2) Or with some kind of explicit indication, like: Arm with clue for treasure? (4,2) Or: Arm with treasure, cryptically? (4,2) 3. With the above example, would this have to be a down clue? 4. Finally, do you only like them with required fodder in plain sight: Arm with loot? In this last example, up *can* be an anagrind, so if your answer to 3, was down only, would you be happy with this one as an across solution? Feel free to expand the discussion! Cheers!

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

8 comments

My opinions: 1. Love them; 2. Strongly prefer the indication; 3. I think it should be a down clue, but you could somehow "indicate" the down-ness of the "clue" in the indicator; 4. Fine without plain fodder, just a bit harder. Not a massive fan of up as an anagrind in general though ;)

G
Last reply 2 wk agoView thread

I'm almost in total agreement with NBW (including dislike of "Up" as anagrind*†) except I'd downgrade "love them" to "like 'em now and again as a solver and find them a useful way to inject variety as a setter". *It's a bit naff cos 1. it's so much more intuitive as a reversal ind, the 2. "up in arms" sense is weak, and 3. the "what's up"/"something's up" sense doesn't "detach" from those phrases, so "fodder up" is nonsense) †Methuselah used it recently & I wish to disassociate myself from him

A
F
G
Last reply 2 wk agoView thread