Letter selection
Sign in to leave a comment
Sign in to leave a comment
I have trouble finding ways to do this. I feel one of the only ways to achieve taking BR from broken would be to play with fractions, e.g., 'broken with 1/3 left' = 'BR', another way could be 'first couple from ...', etc. For the letter selectors from any position, 'second to/for/from', 'third to/for/from', etc., seem to be the only way. If I'm missing other ways to do these, please provide some insight.
"First couple from", "Leading couple from", "[fodder]'s first couple" etc would all be conventional ways, and "last couple", "final pair" etc. You pretty much have to be literal with it. Ordinary English often uses e.g. "head" to mean the top part of something, so using it for the top letter is natural, but there are no well-established, non-forced "head"-equivalents for e.g. the second parts of things, so you essentially have to just say "second".
Re "Henry the Third", a lot of editors/fellow setters dislike "the third"=E and prefer "third of [fodder]", "[fodder]'s third" etc, but that's not a specific issue with "third" - the same criticism applies to e.g. "donkey head". The best way I've found to understand it is to say that sure, "donkey head" is a natural phrase in English, but NOT as a reference to a letter. If you wanted to talk about the first letter of "donkey" in real life you'd never say "donkey initial is D".
I agree with the previous comment about fractions (or percentages) but I have also employed “first couple of…” before now. If the starting word has four letters then you have more scope in terms of everyday phrases like “half-cut”, “not half”, “50% off” etc. You can get lucky and find a real word to delete from your fodder to leave only two letters, but some purists dislike the “remove more than you leave” approach!
5 comments