Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

20 comments

Setter

Welcome to my first crossword on this site. All feedback welcome especially if I used the right type description of the type of clue. Tell me what is working well and what would be even better!

Thanks PianoMan, and welcome to MyC! I found lots to like here, lots of concise clues with good wordplay and a decent variety of clue types. Particular favourites were 9a, 17a, 22a and 23d. More specific comments below.

P
M
Last reply 2 wk agoView thread

Thanks PianoMan. My favourites were 10a, 17a, 22a and 23d. More in the replies.

P
M
C
Last reply 2 wk agoView thread

Thanks PianoMan, welcome and and well done on taking the plunge! Plenty to like, and some very nice ideas, with good use of various different clue types. A few comments follow...

P
P
Last reply 2 wk agoView thread

Thanks Piano Man for a good debut. I couldn't solve everything - I revealed 1d, 3d, and 25a. My top picks were 9a, 17a, 12d, 20d, and 23d. Meles & others have given you some very valuable feedback. I would suggest using clueclinic.com & the Chambers Dictionary app if you don't already - they're quite helpful.

P
Last reply 2 wk agoView thread