Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

24 comments

A bit of a mixed bag for me, lots to like but I found some of your wordplay very convoluted. A few more thoughts in reply

G
G
K
Last reply 3 mo agoView thread

Thanks Grebo and welcome to MyCrossword. If this is your first crossword you've done well. I particularly liked 13a, 16a, and 21d. In general your surfaces are good, one of the hardest aspects of writing clues. More comments in reply.

P
G
G
Last reply 3 mo agoView thread

Squidward??! That apart (I assumed that "affect" for "effect" in 24a was a typo, and while I think "on" in 2d is redundant it didn't bother me) I enjoyed this a lot, particularly 21a, 1d, 22d and especially 23a which I thought was really neat.

G
Last reply 3 mo agoView thread

Thanks for the fun puzzle, Grebo. There are some lovely ideas here, and you clearly have a good eye/ear for interesting surfaces/wordplay. My favourite clues are 18a, 6d and 21d. Some clues such as 4a could become wonderful with a bit of tweaking. If you like you can watch/hear me solve this at twitch.tv/contocrosswords - if you do I hope it's fun/useful. Thanks again!

G
Last reply 3 mo agoView thread

Thanks Grebo. This may not be your first on here, but it's the first I've done and I enjoyed it. A belated welcome to the site. You have certainly produced some nice surfaces and you've kept them succinct. 4a, 13a, 1d, 21d and 22d were my faves. Thanks. PM

G
P
Last reply 3 mo agoView thread

Thanks Grebo, great puzzle. I found it a tough challenge and I was defeated by 23a. I liked 11a, 16a, 10d. 15d, 19d and 22d. I agree with some of the quibbles others have raised but I like innovative clueing. So don't let the Cryptic Grammar Police grind you down. Keep pushing the boat out!

G
P
Last reply 3 mo agoView thread