Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

23 comments

Hi Eager, welcome to MyC. A decent first attempt with generally good surfaces. However, there are some details that could do with improvement, in the replies

D
Last reply 5 mo agoView thread

I enjoyed this a lot ! Neat clueing that yielded to thought. 6d was LOI as it took me ages to spot part of the wordplay. thanks for posting!

I enjoyed this, and I echo Dyno in saying that if this is a first attempt it's a pretty good one. In particular your clues are concise and your surfaces are good. Favourites 13a, 3d, 8d, 15d a creditable near miss. Spoilery comments in reply.

F
G
Last reply 5 mo agoView thread

Deleted

Gentle but satisfying debut. Thanks Eager.

Thanks EA1stD. 8d was my favourite. Nice surfaces and I finished it easily enough but I think the cryptic grammar police would be after you for some of the clues. More in reply.

E
C
Last reply 5 mo agoView thread

Now that was fun, a nice mix of clues and a good level of difficulty for me. 1d was fun, I liked 22a and of course who doesn't love 7a (the drink!)?

Setter

Thank you everyone for your comments on my first grid, definitely lots of useful feedback that I'll keep in mind for my next one!