Special Instructions: A fully revised version of my first ever puzzle. Original clues, and my comments on those, in the annotations. My overall verdict beneath the first comment...

Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

8 comments

Setter

Overall verdict on the original clues (in annotations) below...

A
Last reply 7 mo agoView thread

The early omission aside, that was fun Amoeba. I particularly like 14a, 18a, 11d, 15d, 24d, 27d, 28d but it was as interesting to see the progression you've made (loads). What timescale are we looking at?

A
Last reply 7 mo agoView thread

You certainly gave yourself some tricky words to clue in that first attempt, Amoeba. The refreshed version has some nice ideas and I needed to return with fresh eyes this morning to crack the last half dozen or so. 15a, 15d (very good), 29a (bit of a handful) and 27d were the last few to fall. Oh, and 17a which is certainly not clued as it would have been back when you started! 14a, 18a, 25a, 2d, 3d, 6d, 11d, 16d and 22d my faves. Thanks. PM

A
Last reply 7 mo agoView thread

Thanks Amoeba. I started this soon after you posted it but have only just managed to come back to finish it. Very glad I did - lots of cracking clues and interesting to see the (massive) progression in a relatively short time. Favourites: 18a, 26a, 4d, 5d, 6d, 8d and 27d.