Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

3 comments

Welcome to MyCrossword Croup, and congratulations on your debut contribution. A good mix of difficulty in this puzzle, some items in which did defeat me. Plaudits for 12a, 16a, 21a, 2d, 18d etc. Others I got ok, but couldn’t fully parse the wordplay. I find that using the ‘explanation’ field and making annotated solutions available helps both setter and solver. Look forward to future contributions from you.

C
Last reply 2 yr agoView thread

Well done on the debut, Croup. Some nice ideas - I liked 16a, 21a, 18d. To make one practical suggestion, think about the surface readings of your clues - it's best from a solver's point of view if they can create some kind of natural meaning or a convincing mental image. Some of your clues (eg 1a and 7d) work well in this respect, but you have one or two (eg 10a) that read more like a random jumble of words. But this gets easier with practice, so stick at it!