Sign in to leave a comment

Sign in to leave a comment

20 comments

Setter

Welcome to my first crossword on this site. All feedback welcome especially if I used the right type description of the type of clue. Tell me what is working well and what would be even better!

Thanks PianoMan, and welcome to MyC! I found lots to like here, lots of concise clues with good wordplay and a decent variety of clue types. Particular favourites were 9a, 17a, 22a and 23d. More specific comments below.

P
M
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Thanks PianoMan. My favourites were 10a, 17a, 22a and 23d. More in the replies.

P
M
C
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Thanks PianoMan, welcome and and well done on taking the plunge! Plenty to like, and some very nice ideas, with good use of various different clue types. A few comments follow...

P
P
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread

Thanks Piano Man for a good debut. I couldn't solve everything - I revealed 1d, 3d, and 25a. My top picks were 9a, 17a, 12d, 20d, and 23d. Meles & others have given you some very valuable feedback. I would suggest using clueclinic.com & the Chambers Dictionary app if you don't already - they're quite helpful.

P
Last reply 10 mo agoView thread